Out of Print Doesn’t Always Mean Expensive
When Rarity Fools Sellers — and Buyers Too
In the tarot resale world, the words “out of print” can trigger excitement — and sometimes sticker shock. It’s easy to assume that if a deck is no longer available, it must be valuable. But rarity alone doesn’t guarantee a high resale price. Some decks skyrocket after going out of print, while others fade quietly, even if they’re hard to find.
Understanding what really drives value can help you price more fairly, buy more wisely, and avoid disappointment — whether you're a collector, a reader, or a seller.
The Truth About Rarity and Demand
It’s common to think that if a deck isn’t being printed anymore, it must be valuable. But scarcity is only one part of the equation. A deck can be rare and still not command a high price — especially if no one’s looking for it.
Before assuming value, ask:
Is there actual demand from collectors or readers?
Are similar copies selling at high prices — or just listed at them?
Are unsold listings stacking up across platforms? (consider how many are sold lisings compared to active listings)
The reality is: supply only matters when paired with demand.
Why Some Out-of-Print Decks Stay Affordable
Not every OOP deck becomes a treasure. Some are priced modestly — or even remain unsold — because of a few common reasons:
It was mass-produced before being discontinued
The artwork or theme feels outdated or lacks appeal
It’s incomplete (missing guidebook, box, or cards)
A new or updated version is now available
The creator isn’t active in the community or didn’t build a strong following
Collectors often value decks that spark conversation, evoke nostalgia, or offer unique perspectives. If a deck doesn’t strike that chord, it might stay overlooked — regardless of its print status.
Price Listings vs. Actual Sales
One of the most misleading practices in tarot resale is assuming that listing prices reflect value. Many sellers set high prices based on emotion, assumption, or wishful thinking — not market behavior.
Instead of relying on current listings, always look at sold listings. Search eBay, Etsy, or Facebook tarot groups for completed sales. This gives a clearer sense of what people are actually paying — not what sellers hope to earn.
Examples of OOP Decks That Vary in Value
Some out-of-print decks do command high prices — but they’re usually the ones with strong community reputations or cult followings.
Higher-value OOP examples:
The Mary-El Tarot (First Edition)
The Bohemian Gothic Tarot (1st Edition)
Limited Kickstarter decks with signed extras or high-quality production
Lower-value OOP examples:
Older mass market decks missing key components
Indie decks with minimal buyer interest or outdated styles
Decks that don't have a loyal following or buzz around them
How to Fairly Price Your Out-of-Print Deck
If you’re thinking of selling, consider these steps:
Search for completed sales — not just listings.
Look through tarot resale groups to gauge interest.
Assess condition honestly: is the deck complete and well-kept?
Guidebook
Original Box
Complete Deck ( vital for tarot readers)
Consider how relevant or desired the theme is today.
Don’t let rarity cloud your judgment — not all rare decks are in demand.
Final Thoughts
Out-of-print status can absolutely contribute to a tarot deck’s value, but it isn’t a guarantee. Real worth is shaped by interest, condition, and timing. Whether you’re buying or selling, approaching OOP decks with a balanced perspective can help you avoid inflated prices or missed opportunities.
Have an out-of-print deck and not sure what it’s worth? We’re here to help. Visit AV Tarot Market for free, no-pressure evaluations or browse our collection of rare and indie decks.
And if you’ve ever scored an amazing deal — or made a pricing mistake — we’d love to hear your story in the comments.