Mass Market vs. Indie: What’s the Difference and Why It Matters
If you’ve ever browsed tarot listings online and wondered why some decks cost $20 while others are over $100, the answer often comes down to one thing: how the deck was produced. Whether you’re a tarot reader, collector, or curious buyer, understanding the difference between mass market and indie decks is key to navigating the tarot world with confidence.
Let’s break down what sets these two categories apart — and why it matters for your wallet, your reading experience, and your spiritual connection.
What Are Mass Market Tarot Decks?
Mass market decks are produced by large publishing houses like U.S. Games, Hay House, or Llewellyn. These decks are widely available, often printed in high volumes, and can be found in major bookstores, online retailers, and metaphysical shops.
Common traits of mass market decks:
Widely distributed through major platforms (Amazon, Barnes & Noble, etc.)
Generally affordable ($15–$35)
Standard cardstock and packaging
Often reprinted or reissued over time
✅ Best for: Beginners, affordability, easy access, gifts
What Are Indie Tarot Decks?
Indie decks are independently published by individual artists or small teams. These are often self-funded through platforms like Kickstarter or sold directly from the creator’s website.
Traits of indie decks:
Smaller print runs (sometimes under 1,000 copies)
Unique or niche themes not found in mass market decks
Higher production quality (linen cardstock, gilding, magnetic boxes)
Often include handwritten notes, certificates, or bonus materials
💎 Best for: Collectors, readers who value aesthetic/energy, those seeking something special
Pricing & Value: Why Indie Often Costs More
Indie creators shoulder the entire cost of production — printing, shipping, marketing, and fulfillment. Their decks may be printed in premium facilities with specialty finishes, and the personal energy they infuse into the process makes them feel sacred, rare, and highly collectible.
Mass market decks, by contrast, benefit from bulk pricing and professional distribution channels, keeping their cost low — but sometimes at the expense of uniqueness or quality.
In short: You’re paying not just for the deck, but for the artistry, risk, and devotion of the creator.
Energetic & Spiritual Differences
While not everyone notices this, many readers describe indie decks as carrying a more “alive” energy. The handmade elements, creator intention, and limited nature of these decks often feel more potent during readings.
That said, plenty of readers form strong bonds with mass market decks too — especially longtime classics like the Rider-Waite-Smith or the Wild Unknown.
Resale Considerations
Mass market decks tend to hold steady or decrease in value over time, unless they go out of print.
Indie decks, especially limited editions, often increase in value on the secondhand market.
Keep original packaging and guidebooks — this adds to both collectible and resale appeal.
Suggested Image Placement
Top of post: Side-by-side comparison of an indie deck and mass market deck (flat lay)
Mid-post: A creator packaging an indie deck with personal touches (stickers, ribbon, note)
End of post: Graphic highlighting 5 key differences (price, packaging, availability, energy, resale value)
Final Thoughts
Whether you gravitate toward indie decks for their soul or mass market decks for their accessibility, there’s room for both in your tarot journey. The key is knowing the difference — so you can choose what best fits your path.
Share with us!
Have a favorite indie or mass market deck? Share it in the comments below or tag us in your #TarotShelfie on Instagram! 💫
Looking to buy or rehome your collection? Explore our curated listings of indie and OOP decks at AV Tarot Market.